A question or a proposition?

When does your topic become a conversation, and when a debate?

On Debaty you can start two things, and the difference comes down to a single field.

A conversation: you ask a question

You have a question and you are curious what others think. There is no side to pick; people simply reply.

  • "How do we keep rural public transport running?"
  • "What actually helps against loneliness in your neighbourhood?"

This is what you get if you fill in nothing extra. So you do not need an opinion to start something.

A debate: you put up a proposition

You have a statement people can agree or disagree with, and you want to see how that splits. Replies take a side — for, against or nuanced — and you see the balance.

  • "The city centre should be car-free."
  • "Nuclear power belongs in the energy mix."

A good proposition is testable: a case can be made both for and against. A question is not, and that is not a flaw — it is a different conversation.

Not sure?

Start with the question. You can always add a proposition later; everything already written stays where it is, and the link keeps working. The other way round works too, as long as nobody has picked a side yet.

More about the step itself: Starting a debate and Propositions and stances.

Was this helpful?